CINEMA

Prey

POSTED BY: BRENDA
UPDATED: Thursday, May 16, 2024 23:57
SHORT URL:
VIEWED: 226
PAGE 1 of 1

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:23 PM

BRENDA


Just finished watching watching the latest Predator movie called ,"Prey". It was an interesting spin on the franchise. Good story it moved well. I liked it.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 2:19 PM

WHOZIT


Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
Just finished watching watching the latest Predator movie called ,"Prey". It was an interesting spin on the franchise. Good story it moved well. I liked it.



I haven't heard of this flick

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 3:21 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

Originally posted by whozit:
Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
Just finished watching watching the latest Predator movie called ,"Prey". It was an interesting spin on the franchise. Good story it moved well. I liked it.



I haven't heard of this flick




Yeah. I remember hearing about it a year or two ago. It actually seemed somewhat interesting.

As well as I can remember I don't recall anybody bashing it for DEI or anything like that, and though it may not have been raved about I don't remember any real complaints about it either. I actually think I remember some people praising it for finally being a good Predator movie for the first time in decades.

If memory serves, and Brenda can correct me if I'm wrong, it centers around earlier times in history and either Native Americans or Native Canadians? And I believe the main character is either a girl or a young woman from one of the tribes?

I'm fine with that and wouldn't call it woke at all. There's no reason why Predators couldn't be coming to Earth for a hunt a hundred, 200 or even 1,000 years before we first saw them in the 1980s. And as long as the girl/young woman doesn't have superhero powers or there aren't any scenes where a 100 lb woman physically beats down a monster 3 times her size, they can do it in a way where she can outsmart her adversary in a believable way.

The only two reasons I have never gotten around to watch it is that I hardly watch anything, and (at least prior to this) Hollywood hasn't managed to make a good Predator movie since Predator II, so I'd been kind of turned off by the idea of watching another one after wasting my time with things like AvP.

If you do end up watching it too Whozit, I'd like to hear you post your opinion about it here as well.

--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 4:40 PM

BRENDA


Quote:

Originally posted by 6ixStringJack:
Quote:

Originally posted by whozit:
Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
Just finished watching watching the latest Predator movie called ,"Prey". It was an interesting spin on the franchise. Good story it moved well. I liked it.



I haven't heard of this flick




Yeah. I remember hearing about it a year or two ago. It actually seemed somewhat interesting.

As well as I can remember I don't recall anybody bashing it for DEI or anything like that, and though it may not have been raved about I don't remember any real complaints about it either. I actually think I remember some people praising it for finally being a good Predator movie for the first time in decades.

If memory serves, and Brenda can correct me if I'm wrong, it centers around earlier times in history and either Native Americans or Native Canadians? And I believe the main character is either a girl or a young woman from one of the tribes?

I'm fine with that and wouldn't call it woke at all. There's no reason why Predators couldn't be coming to Earth for a hunt a hundred, 200 or even 1,000 years before we first saw them in the 1980s. And as long as the girl/young woman doesn't have superhero powers or there aren't any scenes where a 100 lb woman physically beats down a monster 3 times her size, they can do it in a way where she can outsmart her adversary in a believable way.

The only two reasons I have never gotten around to watch it is that I hardly watch anything, and (at least prior to this) Hollywood hasn't managed to make a good Predator movie since Predator II, so I'd been kind of turned off by the idea of watching another one after wasting my time with things like AvP.

If you do end up watching it too Whozit, I'd like to hear you post your opinion about it here as well.

--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.



You are correct SIX. The story centres around a young Comanche woman and it is set in 1791.

She had no super powers she was just very good at tracking and reading animals signs. Her brother and some other young warriors thought they were just hunting a cougar but she knew it wasn't just a big cat. Her and her brother brought the cat down and I don't know about adding any more spoilers because of whozit.

It does delve a little into the culture of the Comanche as the young woman learned medicine from her mother but she is also a warrior. Which was common for her people.
She also made first contact with the white man. A group of trappers, hunting small game and bison. Her dog got caught in one of their traps, but the trappers weren't seen for a while more until she stumbles upon a herd of dead bison. Typical style of profiteers, take the hides and leave the meat to rot in the sun. Oddly enough they made the trappers French. *L*

I'm laughing as it is kind of an insult to my French Canadian great grandfather who was a trapper. Don't know if he went after bison though.

As I said up a bit. She is a perfectly normal young woman, who just uses her knowledge to do what she has to do to protect her people.

Very refreshing for me.


NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 6:09 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

BRENDA:

You are correct SIX. The story centres around a young Comanche woman and it is set in 1791.

She had no super powers she was just very good at tracking and reading animals signs. Her brother and some other young warriors thought they were just hunting a cougar but she knew it wasn't just a big cat. Her and her brother brought the cat down and I don't know about adding any more spoilers because of whozit.

It does delve a little into the culture of the Comanche as the young woman learned medicine from her mother but she is also a warrior. Which was common for her people.
She also made first contact with the white man. A group of trappers, hunting small game and bison. Her dog got caught in one of their traps, but the trappers weren't seen for a while more until she stumbles upon a herd of dead bison. Typical style of profiteers, take the hides and leave the meat to rot in the sun. Oddly enough they made the trappers French. *L*

I'm laughing as it is kind of an insult to my French Canadian great grandfather who was a trapper. Don't know if he went after bison though.



I appreciate no spoilers, since this one is probably on my list of movies I will eventually get to watching.



Quote:

As I said up a bit. She is a perfectly normal young woman, who just uses her knowledge to do what she has to do to protect her people.

Very refreshing for me.



I think that's refreshing for all of us.

I think it was especially refreshing back in 2022, which is probably why I remembered as much about it as I did.

What a lot of people don't understand because of the Media is that us white dudes have never complained about women in leading rolls. Not once. But when you're talking about situations where a woman is just badass because "woman" and nothing is earned, nobody wants to see yet another movie where frail little things are constantly beating the shit out of men twice their size because they're just perfect at everything they do because "woman".

I loved Fallout, and I love the main character of Lucy. As I said when the trailer dropped, there were ways for them to do her character where people would love her, and there were plenty of ways for them to do her character that would be completely unbelievable and people would hate her. They actually got it right. All of it. She wraps up after 8 episodes being kind of a badass herself, but it was all earned. She's been through a lot of shit. But despite how bad it all was, she's still that idealistic and naive young girl raised in paradise compared to what people have been living with on the surface and still believes in the good side of people.

THAT'S what we've been starved of for a very, very long time in Cinema and TV.

I'm glad that overall things seem to be turning around back to good story telling, and I'm pretty impressed that the makers of "Prey" managed to do that about 2 years ahead of the curve.

I definitely should give this one a watch. Thanks for reminding me that it was a movie that was made.



--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 6:24 PM

ANONYMOUSE


As shown in Predator 2,, they've been coming at least since 1715 - the flintlock from Raphael Aidolimi was dated 1715. Likely they've been coming since we first developed firearms and therefore became interesting to them.

In my own fanfic on FanFic.net, Night Watch, there's evidence to suggest they've been coming for at least 9,000 years. Maybe they didn't have such advanced weaponry then, so even without our firearms it was a more even match.

NOTIFY: N   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 7:47 PM

BRENDA


Quote:

Originally posted by 6ixStringJack:
Quote:

BRENDA:

You are correct SIX. The story centres around a young Comanche woman and it is set in 1791.

She had no super powers she was just very good at tracking and reading animals signs. Her brother and some other young warriors thought they were just hunting a cougar but she knew it wasn't just a big cat. Her and her brother brought the cat down and I don't know about adding any more spoilers because of whozit.

It does delve a little into the culture of the Comanche as the young woman learned medicine from her mother but she is also a warrior. Which was common for her people.
She also made first contact with the white man. A group of trappers, hunting small game and bison. Her dog got caught in one of their traps, but the trappers weren't seen for a while more until she stumbles upon a herd of dead bison. Typical style of profiteers, take the hides and leave the meat to rot in the sun. Oddly enough they made the trappers French. *L*

I'm laughing as it is kind of an insult to my French Canadian great grandfather who was a trapper. Don't know if he went after bison though.



I appreciate no spoilers, since this one is probably on my list of movies I will eventually get to watching.



Quote:

As I said up a bit. She is a perfectly normal young woman, who just uses her knowledge to do what she has to do to protect her people.

Very refreshing for me.



I think that's refreshing for all of us.

I think it was especially refreshing back in 2022, which is probably why I remembered as much about it as I did.

What a lot of people don't understand because of the Media is that us white dudes have never complained about women in leading rolls. Not once. But when you're talking about situations where a woman is just badass because "woman" and nothing is earned, nobody wants to see yet another movie where frail little things are constantly beating the shit out of men twice their size because they're just perfect at everything they do because "woman".

I loved Fallout, and I love the main character of Lucy. As I said when the trailer dropped, there were ways for them to do her character where people would love her, and there were plenty of ways for them to do her character that would be completely unbelievable and people would hate her. They actually got it right. All of it. She wraps up after 8 episodes being kind of a badass herself, but it was all earned. She's been through a lot of shit. But despite how bad it all was, she's still that idealistic and naive young girl raised in paradise compared to what people have been living with on the surface and still believes in the good side of people.

THAT'S what we've been starved of for a very, very long time in Cinema and TV.

I'm glad that overall things seem to be turning around back to good story telling, and I'm pretty impressed that the makers of "Prey" managed to do that about 2 years ahead of the curve.

I definitely should give this one a watch. Thanks for reminding me that it was a movie that was made.



--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.



I tried to not be spoilery as you said and whozit said that you hadn't seen it. I've been waiting to find a copy at my local library and you can see the whys of that.

I'll also mention there is the usual family dynamics going on. Her mother taught her about making medicine and is worried about her. Her older brother doesn't think she is right but finally has to give in. Also normal. Just life and just being who she is and that was accepted by her people.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 7:55 PM

JEWELSTAITEFAN


This was from 2022. Another Prey is 2024.

So that was the summer of Maverick.

I had thought I'd seen the most recent Predator entry, but that was a different film. Don't think I've seen this one.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 8:59 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

Originally posted by Anonymouse:
As shown in Predator 2,, they've been coming at least since 1715 - the flintlock from Raphael Aidolimi was dated 1715. Likely they've been coming since we first developed firearms and therefore became interesting to them.

In my own fanfic on FanFic.net, Night Watch, there's evidence to suggest they've been coming for at least 9,000 years. Maybe they didn't have such advanced weaponry then, so even without our firearms it was a more even match.



Good point, Anonymouse.

I probably haven't watched Predator II since the early/mid 90's and I totally forgot about the flintlock and how far back that would have dated Predator appearances. And since that means I would have seen it on something no bigger than a 36" tube TV, I might not have even been able to make out any details of the gun at the time anyhow.

But I do remember that scene very well and my brother and I thinking how awesome it was that there was a Xenomorph skull trophy in there. Shortly after that we got to play the Aliens vs. Predator arcade game and our imaginations were running wild about what an Aliens vs. Predator movie would look like. Then something like 15 years later they finally get around to making one and it was complete horseshit.



--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:03 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

Originally posted by JEWELSTAITEFAN:
This was from 2022. Another Prey is 2024.

So that was the summer of Maverick.

I had thought I'd seen the most recent Predator entry, but that was a different film. Don't think I've seen this one.



I don't recall if it got a theatrical release or if it was just a Netflix or Amazon exclusive.

Doing a quick search on the-numbers.com only leads to a different Prey movie from 2021, and when I search for Prey on BoxOfficeMojo I don't see it at all there either.

Pretty sure it was made for streaming, which is probably why you missed it. I only heard about it because some of the regulars I watch on youtube mentioned it for a week or two and then I never heard anybody bring it up again.

--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:05 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
I tried to not be spoilery as you said and whozit said that you hadn't seen it. I've been waiting to find a copy at my local library and you can see the whys of that.

I'll also mention there is the usual family dynamics going on. Her mother taught her about making medicine and is worried about her. Her older brother doesn't think she is right but finally has to give in. Also normal. Just life and just being who she is and that was accepted by her people.



Sounds good to me. I'm pretty much sold on it.

Thanks for bringing it up.

--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 10:31 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Just looked into it and it was made by 20th Century Studios and it was released on Hulu and Disney+ with no theatrical release outside of a screening at the San Diego Comic Con in 2022.

Apparently Disney only wanted to release bad movies in the theaters in 2022 as well.



--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 7, 2024 11:26 PM

BRENDA


Quote:

Originally posted by 6ixStringJack:
Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
I tried to not be spoilery as you said and whozit said that you hadn't seen it. I've been waiting to find a copy at my local library and you can see the whys of that.

I'll also mention there is the usual family dynamics going on. Her mother taught her about making medicine and is worried about her. Her older brother doesn't think she is right but finally has to give in. Also normal. Just life and just being who she is and that was accepted by her people.



Sounds good to me. I'm pretty much sold on it.

Thanks for bringing it up.

--------------------------------------------------

Political correctness is just tyranny, with a smiley face.



You are most welcome.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Wednesday, May 8, 2024 7:52 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


So I watched it...

It was enjoyable enough. Better than AvP and whatever other Aliens and/or Predator movies I've seen post Predator II or Alien: Resurrection, for sure.

Here's my thoughts on it. (*****SPOILER WARNING AHEAD******).

PROS:

1. The setting and cinematography. I thought it was filmed beautifully, and I love going back to the wildlife setting in a Predator movie.

2. The early Native American perspective was a nice change of pace, along with the French trappers who were only slightly more advanced technologically over them compared to the Predator. Unlike the AvP style garbage where we live in a world where top scientist and government types are well aware of all of this, you're thrust back into a world where we don't know shit about anything and this "should" be terrifying.

3. I liked the acting well enough, although I don't think that they were really given too much to work with script wise.


CONS:

1. The sub-titles. Not sure if I just got bad ones or not, but I don't like it when there are foreign languages being used and the subtitles are not in English. It didn't happen too often in the movie, but there were enough scenes where you just have to assume you know what they're talking about based off of the situation and their reactions alone. I also found it jarring that all the Natives spoke crystal clear English most of the movie, except for when they didn't.

2. The Predator is a dick. At least in the newer movies the humans have some sort of way of fighting back, but this Predator was basically just taking a shotgun and shooting an aquarium to smithereens with it. Although they did tone down the capabilities of the Predators somewhat in this movie, the gap between what defenses the humans had against the Predator was amplified by 100 times.

And I do understand that it could be interesting to show that maybe the Predator's arsenal was quite a bit weaker 200-300 years earlier than the original movies, but it's not very convincing when you consider they're still capable of interstellar travel and they have cloaking technology. I'm really not buying that instead of having high powered explosive laser weaponry from the first few movies that he's got nothing but ordinary bolts to fire out here. It is possible that this isn't true and the Predator chose to outfit themselves with inferior weaponry because of how primitive everyone on earth was a, but that isn't hinted at. Although, to be fair, given the nature of these movies I don't know how you really could get that point across even if you wanted to.

3. It was a little too "Girl Power" for my tastes. And I really did try to go into this with as much as an open mind as I could.

In the beginning, my first warning signs on this issue were everyone in her tribe telling her she couldn't hunt, which is basically every flashback Carol Danvers has in Captain Marvel.

The next warning signs were, just after showing how skilled the men in the tribe could hunt when they showed her older brother effortlessly shoot down a hawk that looked to be over a mile or two away with an arrow, they spend the 2nd act of the movie making her look great by making all the hunting males in her tribe lower-double-digit-IQ levels of stupid. I felt they dumbed them down so much that there was no reasonable expectation for the audience to believe this tribe could even have survived on its own against real wildlife, let alone defend against an alien hunting them. Not only that, but then the scene where she wouldn't go home and the men in her tribe started beating the shit out of her to get her to go home. I don't believe for a second that they would have done that to one of their own women in the first place since especially back in the 1700's women were a prized commodity for a tribe, but again, they had her beating one of her own back so hard he couldn't even talk right when she got through with him. This is supposed to be one of the guys the tribe relies on to hunt and protect them?

Then by the 3rd act, any pretense of realism just gets thrown out the window and this girl who couldn't weigh more than 90lbs is outmaneuvering and even out-battling the Predator in physical combat. In order to make this work they had to dumb down the Predator itself. I like that she set up traps and did some of the things that I was hoping for, but we just saw this thing beat the shit out of a huge bear, gut it and then lift it over its head with ease, and we're supposed to buy that this little girl can somehow escape the Predator's grasp when it got on top of her and had her pinned to the ground?

Because of all of this, the ending scene just fell really flat to me. All the young men of the tribe are dead. The only person this tribe now has protecting the children and the elderly from the wildlife and the evil white French men is this one magical girl who killed and severed the head of a monster 3 times her size that had little trouble destroying a bear that would have been 10 times her weight. They'd better go find some more young men, or I don't imagine this tribe is going to survive the next round of French Trappers making it into their area.


I dunno. Maybe I'm too jaded these days to truly shut my brain off and suspend all disbelief and just enjoy a movie for what it is.

Though not even close to the egregious examples of bad movies and TV show messages coming out at the time of its release, I felt that it still had plenty of 2022 Hollywood mentality crammed into it, and I'm now wondering if I was remembering what I thought the people who reviewed it 2 years ago had said about it.

But I guess it's fine. If a little girl saw this movie and looked up to the main girl in this movie, that's no different than a 10 year old boy going to a Spider-Man movie and leaving the theater imagining that they could sling webs and swing from building to building while fighting crime.


I just honestly worry about this type of messaging in movies and TV shows today and how it actually effects the brains of the young people who watch them. There's actually a TikTok movement around young women right this instant where young women (pre-college and in college) are making videos stating that they'd rather be stranded out in the middle of a forest with a bear than with a man. These videos appear to be based off the preconceived ideas that A) a bear can be reasoned with and B) every random man you meet wants to rape you.

I think that young women are being taught lessons that can actually really harm them at some point if they actually believe that they're a lot stronger and physically capable than they actually are in real life.


I really wanted to love the movie Brenda. Sorry. :(


--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Saturday, May 11, 2024 6:45 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


I honestly feel bad that I appear to have killed this conversation.

:(

I didn't hate the movie or anything.

And really my review wasn't meant as a hardcore slight against it, or me telling other people simply not to watch it because it wasn't worth watching. It brought positives to the table as well as my perceived negatives.


I think everybody else probably should give this a watch. Maybe I'm just full of shit and I'm too sensitive about certain things.

I'm sure there's truth to that. Anybody who's read any of my various walls of text in the Cinema thread knows that I hardly ever take any time to actually watch most movies or TV shows. Not just the ones that have come out in recent years. It's like I subconsciously feel like I'm getting myself into a commitment that I don't want to get into unless I'm absolutely sure I'm going to enjoy the experience, so most times I just don't watch.

And I think I kind of pride myself on watching only good things because I choose so little to watch, even though this isn't true and I'd say that only about 60 to 70% of things I've watched in the last 5 or so year's I'd rate between pretty great and excellent. I've seen plenty of things that have let me down and even a pure turd or two along the way. When something doesn't blow my mind I'm salty at myself for the choice I made.

I was positive that I'd love Dream Scenario, and my reaction to it was such a letdown for me. But somebody else could watch it and love it the way I had hoped to. Maybe I should watch it again...

I watched it with my dad the first time, and even though we both wanted to see it I just sometimes get that feeling that I'm responsible for putting somebody else through a bad movie if it isn't immediately apparent it will be a great watch. That feeling alone could be negatively tainting my perception of the Dream Scenario. Maybe I missed something important along the way because I was too inside my own head. It's got a lot of things happening at once. It certainly made you think while you were watching it. Maybe I watch Dream Scenario a second time and I end up loving it?


... and then I remember that I actually got angry after watching The Witch and hating that movie when it was highly recommended by somebody who's sensibilities seemed to align with my own and who's opinion I respected when it came to cinema.

What made it worse for me, and due in no part to the person who made the recommendation, is that I made my brother sit through it. He loves horror movies and even though I don't care much for them, we watch a few together off of his recommendation whenever he's in town, just because I know that it's something he enjoys doing. Some of his horror movies are actually pretty decent, but his bar for enjoying them is much, much lower than mine is. The last time he was here I told him I'd watch a horror movie he wanted me to watch, but we'd watch The Witch the next night, and that's what we did. But those accents were hard to follow and next to impossible to understand without subtitles at some points. My brother has issues with subtitles and I didn't even think to put them on because of him, and I think we both just ended up missing half the meaning of the movie because of it.

But after my feelings on the initial view of the movie subsided, at some point I watched a deep dive video into the meaning of The Witch by a creator I'd never heard of before. And something pretty strange happened. I really enjoyed being led through that movie a second time, with a guide who pointed out things to me that I had missed along the way. It was as if it were a completely different movie than I remembered watching and disliking. I still haven't gotten around to watching The Witch a second time, but I know that I will and I hope to get a lot more out of it, and I'm definitely going to have the subtitles on this time.



I'm not saying that anybody is going to get me to watch Prey a 2nd time, or that I'm any more likely to have any interest in either a new Predator or Aliens movie that comes out after having watched Prey.

But I wouldn't mind seeing more conversation on the movie. Seeing what other people thought of it after they watched it. Even Brenda telling me that I'm full of shit and too sensitive.



It was kind of nice just having 4 people in here talking about the movie. That rarely ever happens on this site anymore.

We should do it more often going forward.

Sorry everybody for killing that vibe here. I'll try not to do it next time.



--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Saturday, May 11, 2024 8:10 PM

BRENDA


SIX, apology accepted and you were in my opinion being hard on the film.

Not all the young men were from what I could see were killed. Just the ones that went out hunting the cat and ended up finding the predator.

I do also feel that you discounted Naru because she was a girl. As I said Comanche women could be warriors which is what she wanted to be. She tried to help the trappers when they encountered the predator as well. Offering medicine to one of them.

Now, I'm not saying that I would watch it a second time either but I can't throw it out.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 14, 2024 8:50 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
SIX, apology accepted and you were in my opinion being hard on the film.



Well... It was an apology directly to you as well as anybody else who participated in the discussion so far. I'm pretty sure it wasn't much of an apology to the movie though.



Quote:

Not all the young men were from what I could see were killed. Just the ones that went out hunting the cat and ended up finding the predator.


That could be true. I wasn't watching it on a big screen TV, so if there were other young men that didn't die I just didn't notice them. I can't recall seeing any men at all in the final scene when she was back with the tribe except for one of the two elders though.

Quote:

I do also feel that you discounted Naru because she was a girl.


Well I can assure you that I didn't and that's not where my complaints about her stem from. I do want to make that clear. I realize that you're being very nice about how you say that, but for years I've been hearing that if I don't like a movie with a strong female lead it's because I'm a misogynist or I just straight up hate women. This has always been an extremely unfair assessment of reality whenever those words have been spoken or put into print.

I absolutely loved the Fallout TV show, and the main person with the most screentime is Lucy. She got herself out of a lot of scrapes too, but there was never a point during the show where I felt it was unearned or beyond belief. And that's despite the fact that she was a wide-eyed, naive, weak little thing in the beginning compared to where Naru already was the first time we meet her.

I think Predator is really hard to do right too. Let's be honest here... by all rights, every character we met in that movie should have been dead at the end of it.

Right off the bat it's hard to believe that a 90 lb girl with a short bow and an ancient gun could somehow kill and sever the head of a vastly technologically advanced alien 3 times her size when an entire group of roided out, highly trained military men including Arnold Schwezenegger and Carl Weathers in their prime didn't survive. It didn't even matter that they had in their possession a Gatling gun that was capable of cutting down an entire forest.

Quote:

As I said Comanche women could be warriors which is what she wanted to be. She tried to help the trappers when they encountered the predator as well. Offering medicine to one of them.


I don't have a problem with the story of a woman warrior, or the fact she wanted to be one. But it does beg the question though, that if Comanche women were allowed to be warriors, why did they go so far out of their way in the first half of the movie to make it VERY clear to the audience that nobody else in her tribe wanted her to be one, including the older women in the tribe?

Just make a movie where Naru is a warrior and let her lead by example. Just show the audience a woman who is strong and already has the respect of her peers and the elders of her tribe because she's already earned that respect off-screen before we meet her. And then all you have to do is make sure you don't make stuff happen on screen that the audience isn't going to believe is possible.

There isn't any need to put those #MeToo-era politics in there. There isn't any reason to clog up half the runtime of a Predator franchise movie with that. There's plenty of great examples of strong, believable, female characters that predate this movie by decades that didn't spend a single second of their time worrying about what The Patriarchy thinks of them and their choices. They're were just people who happened to be women that were bad ass by nature and unapologetic about it. Nobody asked questions about it. We just saw it and we believed it.

I just felt that because they chose to do the story this way and highlight the "struggle" she had as "a woman trying to do a man's job", it detracted from the rest of the story and they had to dumb down other characters, including all of the males and the Predator itself, to make the plot happen.

Quote:

Now, I'm not saying that I would watch it a second time either but I can't throw it out.


Really... I'm just kind of disappointed for you that this movie didn't have a better plot/character arc for Naru. You just don't see too many movies or TV shows that center around Native Americans/Canadians, and you certainly don't see that often at all in Sci-Fi plots. I just feel like they let you down. I think all the parts were there for a much better story, perhaps even a great movie, but they couldn't help but try to inject a bunch of messaging that by nature takes away from a real plot and solid, believable storytelling.

I didn't have a problem at all with Naru's character and personality. She wasn't just some yawn-inducing girlboss who don't need no man and was perfect without having to work at it because "female", like most of the female protagonist of the 2018-2023 era of film making were. She had struggled. And by the end she loses people who were dear to her. She was still learning to be a great warrior and she was earning it and not going around making demands out of everybody without earning the ability to be barking orders. Her motivations were very clear and believable from the beginning of the movie to the end. It's what they did outside of her character to make the plot happen that didn't agree with me.

They had all of the pieces they needed to make a really good movie. They just added a few extra unnecessary pieces that ruined the puzzle, IMO.

They could probably re-shoot less than 10% of this movie, or possibly just edit out about 3 to 5 minutes worth of scenes without any reshoots, and if done right, I'd probably had given it it a B+ or even an A instead of the C-/C that I'd give it right now. And that would be phenomenally high for me, considering my thoughts on the Predator franchise past Predator II.

Nothing in this movie was so offputting that it was close to being unwatchable. It's actually very beautifully filmed in a great setting and it's a shame I didn't watch it on a much bigger screen to take it all in. It's not a bad movie by any stretch. And despite any complaints about it here, I liked it better than any Predator movie I've seen past Predator II. It was better than a LOT of things that were coming out in 2022. It's a shame so few people have seen it.

--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Tuesday, May 14, 2024 11:46 PM

BRENDA


Quote:

Originally posted by 6ixStringJack:
Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
SIX, apology accepted and you were in my opinion being hard on the film.



Well... It was an apology directly to you as well as anybody else who participated in the discussion so far. I'm pretty sure it wasn't much of an apology to the movie though.



Quote:

Not all the young men were from what I could see were killed. Just the ones that went out hunting the cat and ended up finding the predator.


That could be true. I wasn't watching it on a big screen TV, so if there were other young men that didn't die I just didn't notice them. I can't recall seeing any men at all in the final scene when she was back with the tribe except for one of the two elders though.

Quote:

I do also feel that you discounted Naru because she was a girl.


Well I can assure you that I didn't and that's not where my complaints about her stem from. I do want to make that clear. I realize that you're being very nice about how you say that, but for years I've been hearing that if I don't like a movie with a strong female lead it's because I'm a misogynist or I just straight up hate women. This has always been an extremely unfair assessment of reality whenever those words have been spoken or put into print.

I absolutely loved the Fallout TV show, and the main person with the most screentime is Lucy. She got herself out of a lot of scrapes too, but there was never a point during the show where I felt it was unearned or beyond belief. And that's despite the fact that she was a wide-eyed, naive, weak little thing in the beginning compared to where Naru already was the first time we meet her.

I think Predator is really hard to do right too. Let's be honest here... by all rights, every character we met in that movie should have been dead at the end of it.

Right off the bat it's hard to believe that a 90 lb girl with a short bow and an ancient gun could somehow kill and sever the head of a vastly technologically advanced alien 3 times her size when an entire group of roided out, highly trained military men including Arnold Schwezenegger and Carl Weathers in their prime didn't survive. It didn't even matter that they had in their possession a Gatling gun that was capable of cutting down an entire forest.

Quote:

As I said Comanche women could be warriors which is what she wanted to be. She tried to help the trappers when they encountered the predator as well. Offering medicine to one of them.


I don't have a problem with the story of a woman warrior, or the fact she wanted to be one. But it does beg the question though, that if Comanche women were allowed to be warriors, why did they go so far out of their way in the first half of the movie to make it VERY clear to the audience that nobody else in her tribe wanted her to be one, including the older women in the tribe?

Just make a movie where Naru is a warrior and let her lead by example. Just show the audience a woman who is strong and already has the respect of her peers and the elders of her tribe because she's already earned that respect off-screen before we meet her. And then all you have to do is make sure you don't make stuff happen on screen that the audience isn't going to believe is possible.

There isn't any need to put those #MeToo-era politics in there. There isn't any reason to clog up half the runtime of a Predator franchise movie with that. There's plenty of great examples of strong, believable, female characters that predate this movie by decades that didn't spend a single second of their time worrying about what The Patriarchy thinks of them and their choices. They're were just people who happened to be women that were bad ass by nature and unapologetic about it. Nobody asked questions about it. We just saw it and we believed it.

I just felt that because they chose to do the story this way and highlight the "struggle" she had as "a woman trying to do a man's job", it detracted from the rest of the story and they had to dumb down other characters, including all of the males and the Predator itself, to make the plot happen.

Quote:

Now, I'm not saying that I would watch it a second time either but I can't throw it out.



Really... I'm just kind of disappointed for you that this movie didn't have a better plot/character arc for Naru. You just don't see too many movies or TV shows that center around Native Americans/Canadians, and you certainly don't see that often at all in Sci-Fi plots. I just feel like they let you down. I think all the parts were there for a much better story, perhaps even a great movie, but they couldn't help but try to inject a bunch of messaging that by nature takes away from a real plot and solid, believable storytelling.

I didn't have a problem at all with Naru's character and personality. She wasn't just some yawn-inducing girlboss who don't need no man and was perfect without having to work at it because "female", like most of the female protagonist of the 2018-2023 era of film making were. She had struggled. And by the end she loses people who were dear to her. She was still learning to be a great warrior and she was earning it and not going around making demands out of everybody without earning the ability to be barking orders. Her motivations were very clear and believable from the beginning of the movie to the end. It's what they did outside of her character to make the plot happen that didn't agree with me.

They had all of the pieces they needed to make a really good movie. They just added a few extra unnecessary pieces that ruined the puzzle, IMO.

They could probably re-shoot less than 10% of this movie, or possibly just edit out about 3 to 5 minutes worth of scenes without any reshoots, and if done right, I'd probably had given it it a B+ or even an A instead of the C-/C that I'd give it right now. And that would be phenomenally high for me, considering my thoughts on the Predator franchise past Predator II.

Nothing in this movie was so offputting that it was close to being unwatchable. It's actually very beautifully filmed in a great setting and it's a shame I didn't watch it on a much bigger screen to take it all in. It's not a bad movie by any stretch. And despite any complaints about it here, I liked it better than any Predator movie I've seen past Predator II. It was better than a LOT of things that were coming out in 2022. It's a shame so few people have seen it.

--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.



I wouldn't worry about apologizing to the movie.

There were a couple of young men but mostly buried in the back. I had to look for them. You are right the elders were out in front.

I've never seen Fallout so I can't speak to it. Her mother's worry about her was clear and after the brother brought her back to camp. I think that was what made her mother be so adamant that she not become a warrior but stick to medicine.

I can see where you are going and yes, I have seen better Predator movies too.

It could have done with better writing and ideas, true. And it is very rare that you get a whole movie mostly revolving around First Nations from either Canada or the US especially with sci-fi plots.

I think that was what I liked about the movie that was making her way and struggling that she could be a warrior.

If you look back on Native American history some of our greatest war leaders could also have been shaman or medicine men. Men like Sitting Bull or Geronimo both had the makings to be great shaman but chose the way of the warrior, like Naru.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Wednesday, May 15, 2024 4:07 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
I wouldn't worry about apologizing to the movie.



Okay, good. I have never worried about the feelings of a movie before, but I do care about your opinion.



Quote:

There were a couple of young men but mostly buried in the back. I had to look for them. You are right the elders were out in front.


Okay. I will take your word for it. I didn't have my Analytical Hat on to that extent while watching the movie. Nobody jumped out at me at all other than the elders and the little girl who looked up at Naru in awe when she was made war chief, which I'm sure was the intent of the scene as it was filmed.

You would probably know a lot more about tribal life than I would, as I know just about zero and I'm just assuming that you know about your people's history. (I should point that out as being an assumption, since I'm a European mutt myself and I know just about zero history of any of the blood running in my veins)...

What do you think was the "status" of the existing battle-age males of the tribe? Why weren't they themselves hunters? Are they capable at all of hunting and/or learning how to hunt? Was there something wrong with them that they weren't part of the hunting party? Would they be capable of defending the tribe from outsiders now that the hunting party were all killed outside of Naru?

I know it ruins a lot of movies and TV Shows for me, but these are the types of questions I ask when presented with a story. And I find myself imagining what a non-Predator sequel to Prey would look like. Unless Naru's tribe merged with a neutral or friendly local tribe to survive, I'd imagine they'd have to give Naru super powers in order to defend her tribe from rival tribes or the incoming European invaders on her own. Even though I didn't buy her victory over the Predator, there was admittedly a heavy element of luck on her side for it to have happened. And I don't think they tried to hide that luck factor, which is good because it added back some believably to the situation. But you're limited on how often you can throw down the luck card before losing your audience. In order to make a follow up movie or TV show centered around War Chief Naru who's tribe did not merge with another tribe for survival, she can't have that level of luck every single time she goes into battle on her own with other war chiefs or the European invaders that are threatening her tribe.

I think a follow up to what happens to Naru's tribe after the Predator could make a great story if it were written right.

Maybe a book idea for you after you get your first one published?



Quote:

I've never seen Fallout so I can't speak to it.


If you get a chance, you should check it out. I think you'd enjoy it and I'm curious to see what you would think of Lucy and it would better explain what I feel makes a great female character vs. a middling one.

Maybe you could even point out a part where I was being too easy on Lucy and giving her a pass on something I should have been calling out after giving Naru such a hard time.



Quote:

Her mother's worry about her was clear and after the brother brought her back to camp. I think that was what made her mother be so adamant that she not become a warrior but stick to medicine.


Yeah. And I get that. Of course a mother is going to want her child to be safe and not be reckless. It's not a ridiculous scene at all. Like I said, I'm probably just way over-sensitive about this stuff after they pushed it all for so long. I just see this and laugh because I'm sure I could make a video with clips of Prey and everyone telling Naru she shouldn't hunt and should stick to medicine right next to all the Captain Marvel flashbacks with all the men in her life telling her she'd never succeed because she's a woman.

Like... okay. We get it. Can we just go back to writing good strong female characters again? Then we can like, yanno... spend that screen time entertaining everyone with a great story instead of putting the same 20 minute message into every movie which has a female lead in her 20's and 30's from now until the end of time?

Thanks!

Quote:

I can see where you are going and yes, I have seen better Predator movies too.


Which ones have you seen? Which are your favorite?

I've seen Predator, Predator II and AvP for sure. I believe I saw a second AvP, though at this time without bothering to look it up I can't even say for sure there was a second AvP. I obviously didn't care for AvP.

I have to just say that I and II were my favorites. Over time I kind of thought of those two movies as just two parts to a greater whole. To my young boy mind, those stories were so believable and terrifying that I had no problem linking them both together as the same thing. They're both very different movies, and though I haven't seen either of them in probably 25 years, I'd seen them each at least half a dozen times when I was young. I would honestly have to watch both of them again if I were to decide what my actual favorite Predator movie was.

But part of me doesn't like the idea of going back and re-watching them. I've got a picture of the Predator movies that has solidified in my mind over time. Nostalgia is a hell of a drug. Most of the things I revisited from the past did not hold up well over time either because they were just lousy, or my perspective on everything has changed so much over time that those old things are completely not relatable to me anymore. Seeing something and thinking "Why did I like that so much back then?" isn't a great feeling, IMO. That idea alone will probably keep me from ever re-watching the original movies for the first time in nearly 30 years and picking a favorite between them.

Quote:

It could have done with better writing and ideas, true. And it is very rare that you get a whole movie mostly revolving around First Nations from either Canada or the US especially with sci-fi plots.

I think that was what I liked about the movie that was making her way and struggling that she could be a warrior.



Yeah... I get it. And that's why I feel bad that I wrote anything about it and that I apparently just can't help myself from writing more. I just wanted more out of Naru is all.

I'd say that even after Danny Glover pulled off a miracle and defeated the Predator, the idea of the Predator was still just as terrifying as it was when everyone was killed in the first movie. Probably more so when you realize that there's more than one of them, and with the tech they've got available you can assume that there could be millions or even billions more of them on some planet in some solar system that none of us will live long enough to ever travel to. But they can come to us whenever they want to.

But somewhere along the way, they became far less scary. Humans appeared to survive them more and more often. It turns out that they could actually be communicated with and reasoned with. They were pretty much just Klingons with twice the testosterone flowing through their veins who figured out how to cloak their bodies and couldn't speak English.

... And it would appear that they're really, really, really eager to die in battle.

So right off the bat in the 2020's the idea that Naru could defeat the Predator isn't unbelievable. I went into the movie expecting that would be the case. I was looking forward to seeing how they'd do it.

Quote:

If you look back on Native American history some of our greatest war leaders could also have been shaman or medicine men. Men like Sitting Bull or Geronimo both had the makings to be great shaman but chose the way of the warrior, like Naru.


Okay. That answers one of my earlier questions.

So Naru's tribe still has their Military Intelligence, Medical Personnel and War General. Just got to go find some more Soldiers.




--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Thursday, May 16, 2024 12:08 AM

BRENDA


Quote:

Originally posted by 6ixStringJack:
Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
I wouldn't worry about apologizing to the movie.



Okay, good. I have never worried about the feelings of a movie before, but I do care about your opinion.



Quote:

There were a couple of young men but mostly buried in the back. I had to look for them. You are right the elders were out in front.


Okay. I will take your word for it. I didn't have my Analytical Hat on to that extent while watching the movie. Nobody jumped out at me at all other than the elders and the little girl who looked up at Naru in awe when she was made war chief, which I'm sure was the intent of the scene as it was filmed.

You would probably know a lot more about tribal life than I would, as I know just about zero and I'm just assuming that you know about your people's history. (I should point that out as being an assumption, since I'm a European mutt myself and I know just about zero history of any of the blood running in my veins)...

What do you think was the "status" of the existing battle-age males of the tribe? Why weren't they themselves hunters? Are they capable at all of hunting and/or learning how to hunt? Was there something wrong with them that they weren't part of the hunting party? Would they be capable of defending the tribe from outsiders now that the hunting party were all killed outside of Naru?

I know it ruins a lot of movies and TV Shows for me, but these are the types of questions I ask when presented with a story. And I find myself imagining what a non-Predator sequel to Prey would look like. Unless Naru's tribe merged with a neutral or friendly local tribe to survive, I'd imagine they'd have to give Naru super powers in order to defend her tribe from rival tribes or the incoming European invaders on her own. Even though I didn't buy her victory over the Predator, there was admittedly a heavy element of luck on her side for it to have happened. And I don't think they tried to hide that luck factor, which is good because it added back some believably to the situation. But you're limited on how often you can throw down the luck card before losing your audience. In order to make a follow up movie or TV show centered around War Chief Naru who's tribe did not merge with another tribe for survival, she can't have that level of luck every single time she goes into battle on her own with other war chiefs or the European invaders that are threatening her tribe.

I think a follow up to what happens to Naru's tribe after the Predator could make a great story if it were written right.

Maybe a book idea for you after you get your first one published?



Quote:

I've never seen Fallout so I can't speak to it.


If you get a chance, you should check it out. I think you'd enjoy it and I'm curious to see what you would think of Lucy and it would better explain what I feel makes a great female character vs. a middling one.

Maybe you could even point out a part where I was being too easy on Lucy and giving her a pass on something I should have been calling out after giving Naru such a hard time.



Quote:

Her mother's worry about her was clear and after the brother brought her back to camp. I think that was what made her mother be so adamant that she not become a warrior but stick to medicine.


Yeah. And I get that. Of course a mother is going to want her child to be safe and not be reckless. It's not a ridiculous scene at all. Like I said, I'm probably just way over-sensitive about this stuff after they pushed it all for so long. I just see this and laugh because I'm sure I could make a video with clips of Prey and everyone telling Naru she shouldn't hunt and should stick to medicine right next to all the Captain Marvel flashbacks with all the men in her life telling her she'd never succeed because she's a woman.

Like... okay. We get it. Can we just go back to writing good strong female characters again? Then we can like, yanno... spend that screen time entertaining everyone with a great story instead of putting the same 20 minute message into every movie which has a female lead in her 20's and 30's from now until the end of time?

Thanks!

Quote:

I can see where you are going and yes, I have seen better Predator movies too.


Which ones have you seen? Which are your favorite?

I've seen Predator, Predator II and AvP for sure. I believe I saw a second AvP, though at this time without bothering to look it up I can't even say for sure there was a second AvP. I obviously didn't care for AvP.

I have to just say that I and II were my favorites. Over time I kind of thought of those two movies as just two parts to a greater whole. To my young boy mind, those stories were so believable and terrifying that I had no problem linking them both together as the same thing. They're both very different movies, and though I haven't seen either of them in probably 25 years, I'd seen them each at least half a dozen times when I was young. I would honestly have to watch both of them again if I were to decide what my actual favorite Predator movie was.

But part of me doesn't like the idea of going back and re-watching them. I've got a picture of the Predator movies that has solidified in my mind over time. Nostalgia is a hell of a drug. Most of the things I revisited from the past did not hold up well over time either because they were just lousy, or my perspective on everything has changed so much over time that those old things are completely not relatable to me anymore. Seeing something and thinking "Why did I like that so much back then?" isn't a great feeling, IMO. That idea alone will probably keep me from ever re-watching the original movies for the first time in nearly 30 years and picking a favorite between them.

Quote:

It could have done with better writing and ideas, true. And it is very rare that you get a whole movie mostly revolving around First Nations from either Canada or the US especially with sci-fi plots.

I think that was what I liked about the movie that was making her way and struggling that she could be a warrior.



Yeah... I get it. And that's why I feel bad that I wrote anything about it and that I apparently just can't help myself from writing more. I just wanted more out of Naru is all.

I'd say that even after Danny Glover pulled off a miracle and defeated the Predator, the idea of the Predator was still just as terrifying as it was when everyone was killed in the first movie. Probably more so when you realize that there's more than one of them, and with the tech they've got available you can assume that there could be millions or even billions more of them on some planet in some solar system that none of us will live long enough to ever travel to. But they can come to us whenever they want to.

But somewhere along the way, they became far less scary. Humans appeared to survive them more and more often. It turns out that they could actually be communicated with and reasoned with. They were pretty much just Klingons with twice the testosterone flowing through their veins who figured out how to cloak their bodies and couldn't speak English.

... And it would appear that they're really, really, really eager to die in battle.

So right off the bat in the 2020's the idea that Naru could defeat the Predator isn't unbelievable. I went into the movie expecting that would be the case. I was looking forward to seeing how they'd do it.

Quote:

If you look back on Native American history some of our greatest war leaders could also have been shaman or medicine men. Men like Sitting Bull or Geronimo both had the makings to be great shaman but chose the way of the warrior, like Naru.



Okay. That answers one of my earlier questions.

So Naru's tribe still has their Military Intelligence, Medical Personnel and War General. Just got to go find some more Soldiers.




--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.



Well after the ones that went out were killed, I started wondering where the others were as well. So at the end, I was looking.

I would say that I know somethings about a number of the tribes in Canada and the US. Not everything. Women in my tribe could speak at council meetings and when an idea was brought to the council it was looked at whether or not it was good for the tribe, it wasn't based on whether a man or a woman thought of it. My distant aunt Sacajawea was called to a big pow wow before the Little Big Horn, because our chief wanted her words about the white man as she had spent many years among them.

That did puzzle me that there weren't more young men than just the group Naru's brother led. But on the other hand they were such a small band of Comanche that could explain it as well.

At then end Naru said that the band had to move, so it could be possible that they were a splinter group from a main group of Comanche. Maybe they rejoined that group.

There was an element of luck in Naru beating the Predator and like I said they would have to join up with a larger group of Comanche because there weren't enough warriors to defend them from the encroaching white man.

Never know. My main character in my book right now is half-Cheyenne.

I'll have to look for it on YouTube. My library doesn't have Fallout.

I can see your point again.

I've seen Predator and Predator II. Think I've seen AvsP, but I'm not positive. I saw the first Predator because of the Govenator. and it was great film. Saw the second because I wanted to see what else they were going to do and of course Danny Glover as well. Both great films and I've thought about rewatching them myself too.

Thing is with there being only one, we don't know how long they live. Maybe this is a ritual the young ones of the Predator species has to go through and they are given all this tech and are told, "Go out into the Universe and make your mark."

Exactly. Medicine people or shaman, handled injuries or foretold the future. All kinds of stuff like that.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Thursday, May 16, 2024 8:26 PM

JEWELSTAITEFAN


6ix, I was wondering if you ever saw Wind River, from 2017? I know Brenda has.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Thursday, May 16, 2024 10:32 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
Well after the ones that went out were killed, I started wondering where the others were as well. So at the end, I was looking.



Gotcha.

Quote:

I would say that I know somethings about a number of the tribes in Canada and the US. Not everything. Women in my tribe could speak at council meetings and when an idea was brought to the council it was looked at whether or not it was good for the tribe, it wasn't based on whether a man or a woman thought of it. My distant aunt Sacajawea was called to a big pow wow before the Little Big Horn, because our chief wanted her words about the white man as she had spent many years among them.


Like... Sacajawea from the gold plated US coin? No shit?

Hey Sigs. We've got royalty in the house.

Quote:

That did puzzle me that there weren't more young men than just the group Naru's brother led. But on the other hand they were such a small band of Comanche that could explain it as well.


Yeah. You didn't get the feeling it was a very large tribe. I would just imagine for even a tribe of that size there would be more battle ready males than the half-dozen most that we saw. They were the most expendable people in those much harsher times... but only to a certain point. It doesn't matter how many birthing aged women there were back at the settlement if nobody was left to defend it.

But maybe what we saw would have been the right amount? It's not like anybody was expecting a Predator to show up in a spaceship right in their backyard when giving everyone out their job titles.



Quote:

At then end Naru said that the band had to move, so it could be possible that they were a splinter group from a main group of Comanche. Maybe they rejoined that group.


That is a great point. She did say that, and I remeber thinking that's not a bad idea at all, and fast. Never considered the idea that she was maybe reuniting with the larger group. I'm sure given the situation they would have welcomed everyone with open arms.

Quote:

There was an element of luck in Naru beating the Predator and like I said they would have to join up with a larger group of Comanche because there weren't enough warriors to defend them from the encroaching white man.


For sure.

Quote:

Never know. My main character in my book right now is half-Cheyenne.


I smell a potential sequel.

Quote:

I'll have to look for it on YouTube. My library doesn't have Fallout.


It probably wouldn't be for quite a while. I don't know how long Amazon retains their exclusive rights or if they even license any of their stuff out for anybody else to use. Worth a watch whenever you can see it though.

Quote:

I can see your point again.
NGL, I forgot what the point was at this point. But cool.

Quote:

I've seen Predator and Predator II. Think I've seen AvsP, but I'm not positive. I saw the first Predator because of the Govenator. and it was great film. Saw the second because I wanted to see what else they were going to do and of course Danny Glover as well. Both great films and I've thought about rewatching them myself too.


Yeah. They were great.

Quote:

Thing is with there being only one, we don't know how long they live. Maybe this is a ritual the young ones of the Predator species has to go through and they are given all this tech and are told, "Go out into the Universe and make your mark."


Yeah. Good point. They're not really good at making it back home though, are they?

Quote:

Exactly. Medicine people or shaman, handled injuries or foretold the future. All kinds of stuff like that.



Understood.


--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Thursday, May 16, 2024 10:37 PM

6IXSTRINGJACK


Quote:

Originally posted by JEWELSTAITEFAN:
6ix, I was wondering if you ever saw Wind River, from 2017? I know Brenda has.



I have not seen it. Worth a watch then?

--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

Thursday, May 16, 2024 11:57 PM

BRENDA


Quote:

Originally posted by 6ixStringJack:
Quote:

Originally posted by Brenda:
Well after the ones that went out were killed, I started wondering where the others were as well. So at the end, I was looking.



Gotcha.

Quote:

I would say that I know somethings about a number of the tribes in Canada and the US. Not everything. Women in my tribe could speak at council meetings and when an idea was brought to the council it was looked at whether or not it was good for the tribe, it wasn't based on whether a man or a woman thought of it. My distant aunt Sacajawea was called to a big pow wow before the Little Big Horn, because our chief wanted her words about the white man as she had spent many years among them.


Like... Sacajawea from the gold plated US coin? No shit?

Hey Sigs. We've got royalty in the house.

Quote:

That did puzzle me that there weren't more young men than just the group Naru's brother led. But on the other hand they were such a small band of Comanche that could explain it as well.


Yeah. You didn't get the feeling it was a very large tribe. I would just imagine for even a tribe of that size there would be more battle ready males than the half-dozen most that we saw. They were the most expendable people in those much harsher times... but only to a certain point. It doesn't matter how many birthing aged women there were back at the settlement if nobody was left to defend it.

But maybe what we saw would have been the right amount? It's not like anybody was expecting a Predator to show up in a spaceship right in their backyard when giving everyone out their job titles.



Quote:

At then end Naru said that the band had to move, so it could be possible that they were a splinter group from a main group of Comanche. Maybe they rejoined that group.


That is a great point. She did say that, and I remeber thinking that's not a bad idea at all, and fast. Never considered the idea that she was maybe reuniting with the larger group. I'm sure given the situation they would have welcomed everyone with open arms.

Quote:

There was an element of luck in Naru beating the Predator and like I said they would have to join up with a larger group of Comanche because there weren't enough warriors to defend them from the encroaching white man.


For sure.

Quote:

Never know. My main character in my book right now is half-Cheyenne.


I smell a potential sequel.

Quote:

I'll have to look for it on YouTube. My library doesn't have Fallout.


It probably wouldn't be for quite a while. I don't know how long Amazon retains their exclusive rights or if they even license any of their stuff out for anybody else to use. Worth a watch whenever you can see it though.

Quote:

I can see your point again.
NGL, I forgot what the point was at this point. But cool.

Quote:

I've seen Predator and Predator II. Think I've seen AvsP, but I'm not positive. I saw the first Predator because of the Govenator. and it was great film. Saw the second because I wanted to see what else they were going to do and of course Danny Glover as well. Both great films and I've thought about rewatching them myself too.


Yeah. They were great.

Quote:

Thing is with there being only one, we don't know how long they live. Maybe this is a ritual the young ones of the Predator species has to go through and they are given all this tech and are told, "Go out into the Universe and make your mark."


Yeah. Good point. They're not really good at making it back home though, are they?

Quote:

Exactly. Medicine people or shaman, handled injuries or foretold the future. All kinds of stuff like that.



Understood.


--------------------------------------------------

Trump will be fine.
He will also be your next President.



Yeah, I was looking because I wondered at the number of warriors.

And yes, Sacajawea on the $1 US coin that was put out. I still remember the debate about who to put on the coin and when her name came up I was so excited and a little frightened that the US wouldn't be brave enough to do it. But the US government proved me wrong. A number of years ago I found one in some pocket change. Must have been passed by a visitor from the US and they never looked at it just thinking it was a Canadian coin. I keep it for good luck. But before that I traded a Loonie and a Twoonie for 2 Sacajawea US dollar coins with someone I knew in the US. I still have them.

She's my great, great aunt on my father's side. Her brother was chief before a number of years before the Little Big Horn happened. So I am also the great, great granddaughter of a chief.

No, Naru's group wasn't the main tribe. Warriors were expendable to a point as they also hunted for the tribe as well as defended it. Could have been the right amount and of course harsher times. Injuries and sickness would take a toll on a warrior as well.

Naru's band rejoining the main group makes the most sense to me in moving. Greater the numbers more protection.

The white man came in great numbers. S'why the Little Big Horn is so important. 5 tribes banded together and we were able to take out Custer and his regiment.

I don't know about a sequel to my first book. I think that was a one off.

I can keep an eye out for Fallout on YouTube or my library. I actually picked up the first Predator movie today. Thought I give it a rewatch.

I think the point was about nostalgia which can be good or bad. It can either make you happy or sad.

They were good and I think I said the best thing about the first one was that they killed Jesse Ventura off.

No, the Predators don't make it home much. That's what makes me think the ones we see are young and this is a right of passage into adulthood.

And medicine men or shaman if you were a member of the Cherokee, who were farmers before the arrival of the white man also would have foretold when the rains would come to water the "3 Sisters". Those are beans, corn and squash. They would have also been knowledge keepers meaning they could tell stories of how long we have been here.

NOTIFY: Y   |  REPLY  |  REPLY WITH QUOTE  |  TOP  |  HOME  

YOUR OPTIONS

NEW POSTS TODAY

USERPOST DATE

OTHER TOPICS

DISCUSSIONS
The Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes Failure Thread
Sun, May 19, 2024 10:47 - 52 posts
Prey
Thu, May 16, 2024 23:57 - 24 posts
Low rated unwatchable award show postponed until 2025
Sun, May 12, 2024 17:00 - 2 posts
The Twisters Failure Thread
Thu, May 9, 2024 15:17 - 1 posts
The Fall Guy will be another 2024 box office flop
Thu, May 9, 2024 14:54 - 12 posts
Civil War. Probably not the best movie to release in current year, but it does look pretty entertaining...
Tue, May 7, 2024 17:59 - 27 posts
What films are you not looking forward to in 2024?
Tue, May 7, 2024 15:18 - 8 posts
The Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire Failure Thread
Tue, May 7, 2024 15:15 - 60 posts
Horror movies making a comeback?
Tue, May 7, 2024 10:39 - 11 posts
The Fall Guy
Mon, May 6, 2024 22:18 - 3 posts
The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare
Mon, May 6, 2024 00:40 - 6 posts
Hollywood's Abysmal 2024 in Numbers
Sat, May 4, 2024 17:38 - 18 posts

FFF.NET SOCIAL